Login or Register to make a submission.

Manuscript Structure

Manuscripts must follow this exact order: Title, Abstract, Keywords, A. Introduction (Background, Problem Formulation, Research Methods), B. Results and Discussion, C. Conclusion, D. Required Statements, and References. Citations appear as Chicago Full Note footnotes.

Title

  • Word Count: The manuscript must have one English (US) title and one Indonesian title, each exactly 12 words.
  • Content: Both titles must convey the same meaning (they need not be word-for-word translations) and state the legal issue, the jurisdiction or context, and the research approach.
  • Counting Rule: Every string of characters separated by a space counts as one word, including prepositions, conjunctions, and articles. Hyphenated compounds and abbreviations count as one word.
  • Prohibitions: Avoid local abbreviations that are not universally recognized, and generic phrases such as A Study of or A Legal Analysis of.

Abstract

The abstract is the journal's storefront: it largely decides whether the editor sends the manuscript to review or issues a desk rejection.

  • Format & Word Count: Provide an English (US academic) abstract and an Indonesian abstract (Abstrak), each exactly 150 words, in a single, dense paragraph that flows without breaks. The two abstracts must match in content and structure.
  • Restrictions: No citations and no local abbreviations that are not spelled out in universally understood terms.
  • Opening: Open with the problem. Do not spend space on a long macro-level background. In the first one or two sentences, state the core problem: a tension between norms, a regulatory gap, or a blind spot in the prior literature.
  • Objective & Method: State the objective and the method concisely: pure doctrinal, socio-legal, or comparative law.
  • Findings: Give 40% to 50% of the abstract to the key findings and the central argument (thesis statement). Do not make empty promises (e.g., "This article will discuss..."). State the results of the critical analysis and the legal claim the author defends.
  • Tense: Use the past tense for methodological procedures already carried out, and the present tense for the context of the issue and the legal argument.
  • Closing: Close with novelty and prescriptive impact: the theoretical and practical implications for the development of the legal order in the international landscape.

Keywords

  • Quantity & Format: Provide 3 to 5 keywords in English and 3 to 5 in Indonesian, separated by semicolons and listed in the same order in both languages.
  • Specificity: Keywords must be highly specific, academically functional, and search-engine (SEO) friendly (e.g., the name of a theory, a specific concept, or a legal doctrine).
  • Prohibitions: Do not use overly general words such as "Law" or "Statute".

Citation Format (Footnotes)

  • Style: Use the Chicago Manual of Style, Notes-Bibliography system (Full Note). Footnote numbers are placed after the period (.) at the end of the sentence.
  • Books: Every note must include the page number (pinpoint).
  • Journal Articles: Every note and Bibliography entry must include an active DOI (https://doi.org/ format).
  • Legal Documents: Cite statutes, treaties, and court decisions with their official identifiers (statute number, treaty title and article, court, case name, and date), with pinpoint paragraphs or pages, following the Chicago conventions for legal and public documents.
  • Capitalization: Use Capitalize Each Word (Title Case) for book titles and journal names (the first letter of every word is capitalized and the remaining letters stay lowercase).

A. Introduction

1. Background The Background must be comprehensive, analytical, and cohesive, following a deductive "funnel" approach. Guide the reader from the macro issue to the micro issue smoothly, with no subheadings.

  • Proportion: 15% to 20% of the manuscript, roughly 800 to 1,200 words.
  • Opening: Do not open with a cliché philosophical statement, a dictionary definition, or an overly broad general claim. Begin directly with a concrete, pressing problem: a specific legal phenomenon, a clash of norms between the ideal (das Sollen) and the empirical reality (das Sein), a regulatory vacuum, or a controversial judicial decision that has sparked global academic debate.
  • Literature Mapping (State of the Art): Present 5 to 10 relevant, recent sources, generally from reputable journals published in the last 3 to 5 years. Do not summarize prior studies one by one like a catalog. Synthesize by theme, group the scholars' positions, set their arguments against one another, and map the ongoing legal debate. Show why the issue matters globally.
  • Gap Analysis: Identify the research gap convincingly. Highlight the weaknesses, limits, or blind spots of prior work.
  • Legal Novelty: Based on the gap, state the legal novelty and added value explicitly. Use a firm transitional sentence to declare it (e.g., a new conceptual approach, reinterpretation of a rule, etc.).
  • Closing Paragraph: State the thesis statement, which declares the claim or legal position defended throughout the manuscript, and give a short, dense, clear preview of the final findings or the solution offered.
2. Research Questions State the research problem as questions or as a short paragraph. This formulation sets the line of reasoning that the Results and Discussion follows, in the same order.

3. Research Methods The Research Methods must be analytical and operational. Written in formal academic English in the past tense to show that procedures were completed.

  • Proportion: 5% to 10% of the manuscript, roughly 400 to 700 words.
  • Prohibitions: No textbook definitions. Do not quote the definition of a methodology from printed textbooks. Explain step-by-step how the research was carried out.
  • Research Type: Declare the research type clearly (doctrinal, socio-legal, or comparative law).
  • Four Operational Pillars:

    1. Research approach: statutory, conceptual, analytical, or comparative-historical.
    2. Sources of legal materials: Name the primary legal instruments used, such as statute numbers, international treaties, or court decisions (case law).
    3. Collection procedure: Explain transparently, including global databases (e.g., Westlaw, LexisNexis, HUDOC) or official institutions accessed. State inclusion and exclusion criteria (date ranges, keywords, reasons for selection).
    4. Legal analysis technique: Do not merely state "analyzed qualitatively." Describe the "analytical blade" used (systematic interpretation, teleological interpretation, deductive syllogism). Note: Socio-legal research must state the triangulation of field data with regulatory texts, anonymized coding, and research ethics.

B. Results and Discussion

This section is the core of the manuscript. Merge Results and Discussion so that the argument is not interrupted.

  • Proportion: 60% to 70% of the manuscript, roughly 4,000 to 6,000 words.
  • Structure: Divide into thematic or argumentative subsections. Do not simply turn each research question into a subsection title.
  • Analytical Character: Shallow description is strictly prohibited. Do not merely report legal facts, quote articles in full, or copy court decisions without analysis. Every segment must critique and uncover the root of the problem.
  • Reasoning Pattern: Adapt an academic analytical pattern such as IRAC (Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion). Write the argument in the active voice.
  • Theory as a Working Tool: Theories introduced in the Introduction must not be decorative. Operate them as the "blade" to dissect legal materials.
  • Academic Dialogue: Confront, compare, and converse with the state-of-the-art literature to highlight the author's novelty.
  • Escape the Domestic-Jurisdiction Trap: Elevate local/national issues to the broader global discourse. Draw common threads to universal principles of law, constitutional principles, or human rights.
  • Supporting Elements: Graphs, comparison tables, and conceptual diagrams may be added proportionately. Each must be numbered, titled, sourced, and interpreted in the text.

C. Conclusion

  • Write one narrative paragraph that answers the research problem.
  • Maximum of 4 sentences.
  • No numbering, bullet points, new data, or new citations.

D. Required Statements

Six statements are mandatory. They appear after the Conclusion and before the References. Each has its own bold run-in heading, is written in US academic English, and is excluded from the manuscript word count. Authors must replace all bracketed text with actual information.

1. CRediT Authorship Contribution Statement Use the Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT) roles. Identify each author by initials.

CRediT authorship contribution statement. A.B.: Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal analysis, Investigation, Writing – original draft. C.D.: Supervision, Validation, Writing – review & editing.
2. Funding Statement Give the full official name of each funder, the grant/contract number, and the recipient. If no funding was received, use the no-funding variant.

Funding. This work was supported by [Funder Full Name] under Grant No. [number] awarded to [A.B.].
(No-funding variant): Funding. This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
3. Declaration of Competing Interest Disclose any financial and non-financial interests (counsel roles, affiliations, etc.) covering at least the past 36 months.

Declaration of competing interest. The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
(Conflict variant): Declaration of competing interest. Author A.B. served as counsel to a party in [Case Name], which is analyzed in this article. The remaining authors declare no competing interests.
4. Data Availability Statement List where legal materials can be accessed (databases, official gazettes). Deposit compiled datasets in trusted repositories with DOIs.

Data availability. The legal materials analyzed in this study are publicly available from [Official Source or Database Name]. The coded dataset and coding protocol are openly available in [Repository Name] at https://doi.org/[DOI].
(Doctrinal variant): Data availability. This study analyzed only publicly available legal sources, which are cited in full in the footnotes and bibliography. No new datasets were created.
5. Ethics Statement For socio-legal research with human participants, name the approving ethics committee and approval number. For doctrinal research, state it was not required.

Ethics statement. This study was approved by the [Ethics Committee Name] (Approval No. [number], [date]). All participants gave written informed consent before taking part, and all responses were anonymized, coded, and stored securely.
(Doctrinal variant): Ethics statement. This study analyzed only publicly available legal sources and involved no human participants. Therefore, ethical approval and informed consent were not required.
6. Declaration of Generative AI Use Disclose any use of AI tools in the writing process. Authors must take full responsibility for verifying all legal authorities and citations.

Declaration of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process. During the preparation of this work, the authors used [Tool Name, Version, Provider] in [Month Year] to [specific purpose, e.g., improve language and readability]. After using this tool, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed, verified all legal authorities and citations, and take full responsibility for the content of the published article.
(No-AI variant): Declaration of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process. The authors did not use generative AI or AI-assisted technologies in the preparation of this manuscript.

References

  • Minimum Quantity: At least 15 references. Journal articles must carry an active DOI.
  • Format: Chicago Manual of Style, Full Note (footnotes) with a Bibliography at the end. Book entries and notes include page numbers where cited.
  • Text Formatting: Capitalize Each Word (Title Case) for book titles and journal names.

Pre-Submission Checklist

Component Must contain Common reason for rejection
Title 12 words (English US and Indonesian) Incorrect word count
Abstract 150 words (English and Indonesian), one paragraph, no citations "This article will discuss..." instead of findings
Keywords 3 to 5 specific terms (theory, concept, doctrine) Generic words such as "Law"
Background Funnel narrative, no subheadings, state of the art, gap, legal novelty, thesis Catalog-style literature summary
Methods Research type, pinpoint sources, databases, inclusion and exclusion criteria, analysis technique Textbook definitions; "analyzed qualitatively" only
Discussion Thematic subsections, IRAC-style reasoning, dialogue with literature, global elevation Quoting provisions or decisions without analysis
Conclusion One paragraph, maximum 4 sentences Bullet points or new data
Required Statements All six, placeholders replaced Missing or unfilled statements
Footnotes Chicago Full Note after the period, book pages, journal DOIs Missing page numbers or inactive DOIs
References At least 15, Title Case Mixed formats

All submissions must meet the following requirements.

  • This submission meets the requirements outlined in the Author Guidelines.
  • This submission has not been previously published, nor is it before another journal for consideration.
  • All references have been checked for accuracy and completeness.
  • All tables and figures have been numbered and labeled.
  • Permission has been obtained to publish all photos, datasets and other material provided with this submission.